Due to COVID 19, we're providing FREE consultations via PHONE or VIDEO conferencing for your safety and convenience. Please see Our Coronavirus Policy.

“Aggressive” Lawyers Are Often All Smoke And No Fire, Says Central NY Injury Lawyer

Although I am a New York personal injury lawyer 95% of the time, every once in a while I let myself get talked into representing a plaintiff in a non-injury case. Usually it is to sue for breach of contract or something like that. Recently, I had a three-day bench trial (that means it was tried before a judge rather than a jury) on such a case.

My opponent was an ass. He made lots of useless objections, shouted and screamed a lot, and had a very sarcastic tone during his cross-examinations. He never smiled and he had a permanent scowl on his face. He looked mean. This particular lawyer has a reputation for being needlessly aggressive, unlikeable, and unkind. Other lawyers I have talked to about him do not think he is good or effective — he is all smoke and no fire.

He has a steady stream of clients, though. Most of them men are of a certain type. They are the kind of men who have big aggressive dogs. This lawyer is, apparently, some kind of bulldog for them.

When we finished the trial, I thought I had probably won, but the judge wanted to “reserve”, meaning he would write a Decision later.

Three weeks later the Decision arrived. I had won. My client got all the money he had sued for, plus interest. I called him and told him the good news. His response? “I can’t believe we won —- that other lawyer was so aggressive! I thought he had beaten us!”

Moral of the story: Being needlessly mean and “tough” in the courtroom may impress some clients, and even the other lawyer’s clients. But that’s because non-lawyers’ impressions of what good lawyering is comes from TV shows. In the real courtroom, good lawyering means being smart, skillful and persistent — and being likeable can’t hurt, either.

Keep safe!

Mike Bersani
Email me at: bersani@michaels-smolak.com I’d love to hear from you!

Michael G. Bersani, Esq.
Central NY Personal Injury Lawyer
Michaels & Smolak, P.C.


Contact Information